For the listed passive bonuses, Fast Learner leads trait EXP (+10%), Mana Sensitive leads trait Mana recovery (+35%), and Chosen One is the broad survival pick. Devil and Sovereign lead many fields in their historical references. These are goal-based editorial tiers, not a tested Update 2 damage ranking. For books, compare the Grimoire tier list.
Rank for the run you want
Goal tiers compare historical beta bonuses. No live DPS, stacking or win-rate model is assumed.
EXP is the primary comparison. Yuls and combat utility are secondary; there is no measured EXP-per-hour score. S = strongest direct fit in this comparison; A = strong keep; B = narrower useful fit; C = less direct support for this goal. Same-tier entries are not an exact order.
Fast Learner
Highest listed EXP bonus (+10%). Keep it for leveling rather than rerolling only for rarity.
Listed bonuses: +5% Mana regeneration; +10% EXP.
Keep for this goal. Test the same quest or boss before spending more.
Chosen One
Lists +7.5% EXP with broader survivability and Mana support; do not discard a useful existing result.
Listed bonuses: +10% Health; +25% Health regeneration; +10% Stamina; +25% Stamina regeneration; +10% Mana; +25% Mana regeneration; +7.5% EXP.
Keep for this goal. Test the same quest or boss before spending more.
Coin Eye
No EXP bonus is listed. Coin Eye supports Yuls; combat or recovery traits may still improve completed runs.
Listed bonuses: +2.5% Mana regeneration; +5% Yuls.
Reroll only with a reason. Keep an adequate setup while you improve equipment or save a roll budget.
Steady Hands
No EXP bonus is listed. Coin Eye supports Yuls; combat or recovery traits may still improve completed runs.
Listed bonuses: +4% Stamina; +7.5% Stamina regeneration.
Reroll only with a reason. Keep an adequate setup while you improve equipment or save a roll budget.
Thick Skin
No EXP bonus is listed. Coin Eye supports Yuls; combat or recovery traits may still improve completed runs.
Listed bonuses: +4% Health; +7.5% Health regeneration.
Reroll only with a reason. Keep an adequate setup while you improve equipment or save a roll budget.
Iron Lungs
No EXP bonus is listed. Coin Eye supports Yuls; combat or recovery traits may still improve completed runs.
Listed bonuses: +2.5% Stamina; +20% Stamina regeneration.
Reroll only with a reason. Keep an adequate setup while you improve equipment or save a roll budget.
High Mana
No EXP bonus is listed. Coin Eye supports Yuls; combat or recovery traits may still improve completed runs.
Listed bonuses: +25 Mana; +17.5% Mana regeneration.
Reroll only with a reason. Keep an adequate setup while you improve equipment or save a roll budget.
Strong Body
No EXP bonus is listed. Coin Eye supports Yuls; combat or recovery traits may still improve completed runs.
Listed bonuses: +7.5% Health; +22.5% Health regeneration; +5% Stamina; +12.5% Stamina regeneration.
Reroll only with a reason. Keep an adequate setup while you improve equipment or save a roll budget.
Mana Sensitive
No EXP bonus is listed. Coin Eye supports Yuls; combat or recovery traits may still improve completed runs.
Listed bonuses: +10% Health regeneration; +12.5% Mana; +35% Mana regeneration.
Reroll only with a reason. Keep an adequate setup while you improve equipment or save a roll budget.
The best keep depends on one specific goal
The tool’s S/A/B/C groups describe fit for a selected task. A C for EXP means no EXP field is listed; it does not mean the trait is useless or has been measured to clear more slowly. Same-tier entries have no strict order.
| Goal | A useful keep | Why the comparison changes |
|---|---|---|
| Leveling | Fast Learner; an owned Elf/Devil; Royal/Sovereign | Fast Learner lists +10% EXP versus Chosen One’s +7.5%. Do not reroll a useful broad package just to match one field. |
| Equipment money | Merchant or better owned economy class; Coin Eye | Merchant lists +10% Yuls versus Noble’s +7.5%; Noble offers recovery that Merchant does not. |
| Boss survival | Chosen One or Strong Body; a recovery race/class | Health and recovery help between mistakes. They do not bypass Witch Queen’s vessel mechanic. |
| Mana sustain | Mana Sensitive; a useful pool race; Royal/Sovereign | Pool size and regeneration solve different interruptions. Race regeneration is omitted because data conflict. |
Choose a Grimoire by its tools, then check the dated tier
- Already own a useful Shadow or Anti-Magic? The October 12 editorial list rated them S, but grouped base and Devil forms. Keep a working roll while checking the form and unlock you actually have.
- Poison is a historical PvE recommendation for damage while repositioning. It is a candidate to try, not a measured winner on every boss.
- Ice has documented area tools and is a practical early keep; its rank differs between the October 5 and October 12 lists.
- Blood has seven skills but no controlled comparison here. Being new does not automatically make it S tier.
How the goal tiers are made
Clover Time Guide assigns the passive tiers by reading the actual listed bonuses for the chosen goal. S is the strongest direct fit in that reference, A a strong keep, B a narrower useful fit and C a less direct fit. The goal definitions sit above the results. This is our decision aid, not an official developer ranking.
The passive comparison uses historical beta values. No stacking total, rarity-weighted score, acquisition cost or current damage formula is assumed. Flat Mana and percentage Mana remain separate.
Should I keep or reroll?
Progress stays in this browser.
Why newer books can stay unranked
The official Halloween Part 1 event announces three Grimoire rarity slots, a raid/location and level cap 200. The current experience title advertises Blood and Update 2. These announcements establish scope, not a complete tested combat order.
The Grimoire comparison keeps Blood unranked and preserves older data dates. It does not guess the identities, exclusivity or performance of every announced addition.
Questions players ask
What is the best race in Clover Time?
Devil has the largest listed EXP and Mana package among the five historical race records. Keeping an owned Elf or Human-Dwarf can still be a better use of your resources than chasing an unpriced reroll. This is not an Update 2 DPS test.
Is the rarest trait always best?
No. Fast Learner lists more EXP than Chosen One, while Mana Sensitive lists more Mana regeneration. Choose the field you need and keep a useful result.
Does an S tier mean my build will beat Witch Queen?
No. The tiers compare reported passive packages. They do not predict your damage, skill use, party or success with the Blood Vessel mechanic.
